Four practitioners on the tactics people bring into the room, which ones work, and what to do when an offer insults or the talks stall.
Jane Player starts with the tactics she sees most often in commercial disputes, and why she coaches parties away from two of them: putting the bottom line on the table at the outset, and salami slicing, conceding a little at a time until everyone is too tired to settle. Her alternative is to keep every offer “within the pitch”: far enough from your bottom line to leave room to move, close enough not to insult.
Anchoring is the same problem from the other side. Fix on a number too early and it becomes an expectation that is hard to move from, which is why Jane encourages parties to talk about outcomes before money. Sabine Walsh deals with the opposite problem, when nobody wants to make the first offer, and how a mediator helps someone take that first step.
If you want to get to the middle line, which is where your bottom line is, you need to make your offers within the pitch
Interviewer: What are some of the common tactics that people use in negotiation?
Okay, so once you've done an element of exploration of what the other side's viewpoint is, where they're coming from, then you get to the point where in negotiation, you're looking at proposal making. And tactically, there are lots of different things that you can employ. You can be stubborn from the outset, put your position down on the table and say, "I'm not moving from there." That can be quite effective sometimes, rarely, but it can be, if that truly is your position. And some people say, "I'm not messing around today.
"I'm going to tell you where my bottom line is, and that's it." We tend, when we're coaching people, to discourage people from puttin' down their bottom line from the very outset. People would like to know there's a little bit more they can get from you, so, just in terms of how the other side will feel around achieving a good negotiated settlement, we encourage people to have a little bit more to give. So some people come to a negotiation with a bottom line, and they're not prepared to negotiate.
That can be effective. It's rarely so, and that's just because, the personality of the person receiving that will want a little bit movement. And, if you've got nothing else to give, it's not a very satisfactory way of getting to a negotiated settlement. We talk about a salami slicing, and actually, that's hopeless. And you can be there all day, with people just giving a little bit each time and a little bit each time, and it actually, it becomes really debilitating. It causes fatigue, and people get very cross.
And actually, you can see million pound disputes falling away and not settling over the minutest piece of negotiation at the last minute, just because people have had enough. And it almost becomes a matter of principle not to give one more salami slice. So I discourage that kind of tactic, it's not very effective. I often talk to people about a football pitch. If you think of your negotiation in a football pitch, if you make your offer outside the pitch completely, you are likely to insult.
You're likely to cause distress, and you're likely to cause a poor reaction by the other side. If you want to get to the middle line, which is where your bottom line is, you need to make your offers within the pitch, because that won't upset people, but it will give them a rational thought around where you want to get to today. And try to put some degree of reason around what your offer looks like and why you're putting it in the way you're putting it, because people can then unpick it.
And the other tactic that I often take to people is, once you've been given a proposal, you may not like it, but, if you can use the framework that the other side have used, it's a respect piece, and it helps them work with what they've got. You may then, within that framework, throw some parts of it out, 'cause that's not a valid ground for settlement or reduce it, but you're actually using their framework. You'll often find that you can persuade the other side more to come to your viewpoint, than if you try to say, "On any basis, "I'm not even going to use your framework, "and I want to use mine," and then you're trying to compare apples and pears.
Far better to, if it's possible, accept the framework and work within it, because you might then get a better outcome for yourself. So, someone might turn around and say, "We're giving you a basket of proposal." There may be some damages for loss of profit. There may be some proposals for future working. There may be some money compensation, so I've got six heads of claim that I'm going to cater for. Rather than throwing out the heads of claim completely, you might say, "Well, let's look at your heads of claim.
"We aren't going to talk about number four, "because we don't accept that as valid, "but we might actually talk about number three "in a different way." Because, you often find, that people are very granulated at the beginning, and, by the end of the day, when they're negotiating, actually, there's a lump sum that they need. And they might reflect that lump sum in a completely different way from you, but, provided the lump sum is both manageable by you both, does it matter? So, you'll often say to people, and that's why settlement agreements are often very generic, "We don't mind if you want to go back to your head office "or back to your group and say, "'we managed to achieve all of our loss of profits.'" When we've actually seen it as being a completely different reflection of what we're paying for.
As long as you've not called it anything, and the lump sum is the same, does it matter? And sometimes, you're helping parties save face or reflect internally what they've achieved. As long as you don't have to make a public statement in that regard, and in a private negotiation, or a mediation that's without prejudice, it doesn't matter.
It's really difficult if you anchor yourself too soon to move from that.
Interviewer: Another tactic is anchoring. What is it and how does it differ from priming?
So anchoring is difficult. If somebody has a claim of 20 million when they come in and somebody has a counterclaim of 10 million, you've got a big zone in which to try to get an agreement. And if they make strong positions around where they can get to very early on, they might anchor themselves in a expectation level, which is actually unrealistic. And it's really difficult if you anchor yourself too soon to move from that. So that's why we often discourage people to talk about money too soon.
We ask them to talk about where they want to get to in terms of outcomes, but we try to get bottom lines or anchoring later on in the day. And you don't want to have to negotiate against yourselves either. So for example, if you have a claim at a counterclaim at stake, if you know that the counterclaim has only been put forward as a negotiating tactic and actually could be dropped, if the claim is reduced, then to early on get that concession is really, really important to make sure you are properly negotiating within the right kind of zone that you're going to get an agreement.
And one of the things that you do as a neutral is that you can get a feel for where that zone is starting to play itself. And so that's when priming comes in because later on in the day, you understand where you might likely get a settlement to go. So if a party makes a proposal or wants you to take a proposal across to the other side for them, at a level where you know there's no chance is going to be acceptable, your role is to push back and say, "Do you really mean to make me debate that proposal "at that level?
"Do you really expect to get a settlement at that point?" Because if you're too extreme, you will irritate, you will insult, you will stop the flow of the achievements you've made already today in getting a healthy negotiation going. So you coach them to be sensible around their proposals, so that you are bringing them into that zone of potential agreement, the ZOPA we talk about, as quickly as you can. There's nothing worse than someone making a proposal that just puts everyone's back up and you go 10 steps back.
One can make the argument that the person who makes the first offer has an advantage, because they take the serve
Interviewer: What do you do when no one wants to make the first offer?
Yeah, that can be tricky as well, and actually it's a shame, because one can make the argument that the person who makes the first offer has an advantage, because they take the serve, they start the game of tennis, if you like. But, you know, generally, if somebody is refusing to do that, it's, they're probably just not ready or there's still an element of fear or concern around doing that. And one option is to explore that in a private session and say, "Look, I get a sense that we're ready to go into actually making some concrete offers here, but I am sensing a reluctance to do this.
What would make it easier to do this? What might remove the barrier to doing that?" So I would just explore why that is the case, and maybe do a bit of questioning around, "Well, what's the worst thing that can happen?" Because generally, when you ask that question, "What's the worst thing that can happen?" it's that the other side would reject the offer. So if they do that, then you move to a different offer or you explore different alternatives, or you look for a counter offer.
So, really, it's sometimes it's about just removing the perception of being the first person to take the step along the bridge.
We're in a process. Don't walk away, this is what it is. This is just the first offer.
Interviewer: Sue we get to the point without prejudice in negotiation where first offers come through from the other side. How do you go through with the client evaluating that? How do you handle it if the client reacts badly, as often will happen with the first offer as we know? How do you play it?
If the offer comes through to me without the client there, I sort of spend a bit of time working out what I think about it with my team of lawyers, I invariably worked in teams, to see how many boxes it ticks. So whether it's way off the mark. Then I'll, I have a duty, you take it to the client. You can't sugarcoat it. If it's a terrible offer I'll go to the client, and I'll say, "Look, this is the first offer. It's shit, we're not going to take this.
This is what I think. This is where I think it's aimed at. We're in a process. Don't walk away, this is what it is. This is just the first offer." Sometimes clients go, "Well, that's it. This is rude, and this is insulting, and I'm not going to talk to them." You can usually handle that. Because you usually say, "Look, if you were in their shoes, what would you do? You're not going to bid against yourself, so you start at the bottom. We're here for a day, we're going to get up higher, they're still in the room.
They haven't said this is their final offer. So let's see. Let's look at it. Okay, so what are we going to do? How do we respond?" And then you get this whole discussion about I don't want to bid against myself. If it's a totally unreasonable offer, you might as well actually go to the opposite end of the extreme and go back with a, you know, off the other end of the spectrum. And then at least you've got the parameters, with a hope that somewhere in the middle you'll end up, if that's where you want to end up.
It's a crushing moment, isn't it? When you've got a small offer on one side, and then the other client makes that, deducts that sum from their 100% figure inclusive of interest and costs, and everybody despairs. Yeah. But you get through it.
So I think impasse, far from being a negative, is absolutely a positive.
Interviewer: We talk about managing deadlocks or impasses. What's your view on this?
Yeah, well, it's a perennial question and problem. I think the first thing I would say is, I don't have, as a mediator, any fairy dust. And often, people will say, well now Geoff, it's time to earn your fee. Which, I say, but I've been working all day. (laughter) But I think impasse generally is very helpful. So I often talk about false impasse. So, parties, especially in commercial cases, will often get to a point where they're stuck. They're gridlocked, they're deadlocked. They're at impasse.
And often I have this visual in my head where the parties will walk up to the cliff, and they will either hold hands and jump off, and hurt each other by not resolving the matter, or they will look over the cliff into the abyss, and step back. And I think in that sense, impasse is very helpful. They go to the edge of the cliff, they say we don't want to go down there. We will step back and we will modify our positions, to make sure that we can at least talk sensibly about resolution.
So I think impasse, far from being a negative, is absolutely a positive. I choose to see it as a positive, because it is so prevalent in mediation. Often parties will get to, say, a number, and they will be gridlocked. There will be a delta between the numbers. And my job is to bridge that gap. And there's a number of things a mediator will do to bridge the gap. But again, I think you get back to, if you've got the trust and confidence of the parties and they respect your reality testing and your questioning, they will see where, what I call the sweet spot of the resolution is, whether it's numbers or something else.
Sue Prevezer KC has delivered plenty of bad first offers to clients. Her advice is not to sugarcoat it, not to walk away, and not to bid against yourself: a first offer opens the day rather than ending it. Geoff Sharp sees impasse differently from most. Parties walk up to the edge, look over, and step back, and in his view that moment is often what makes settlement possible.
Jane mediates commercial disputes in London, through Jane Player Mediation and Independent Mediators. She practised as a litigation lawyer in England before moving to mediation. Corporate Livewire named her Commercial Mediator of the Year.
Sabine practised as a solicitor for seven or eight years before training as a mediator, and built a practice spanning commercial, civil, family, farming and succession disputes. She co-edited the European Mediation Law Handbook with Nadja Alexander and Martin Svatos.
Sue built her career as a top litigator, instructing and watching a great many mediators, before converting to mediation herself. She is now building her practice as a mediator.
Geoff spent around twenty years as a commercial litigator in New Zealand before moving to mediation in the mid-1990s, and has practised as a full-time mediator since.