Before delving into the differences between the two processes, it is important to point out what the advantages of ADR are over traditional litigation. For most people, when they are in a dispute or have a legal claim, the first thing they think of doing is consulting a lawyer and going to the courts.
However, litigation is usually costly and it can take a long time to reach resolution. Even then, the parties might not be happy with the outcome.
Why would anyone choose a private process when the courts are available? Brian Hutchinson, Associate Professor at UCD Sutherland School of Law and a Chartered Arbitrator, gives the practical reasons: timing, expertise and privacy. He also warns that arbitration is not necessarily softer than going to court.
Interviewer: Why is there a need for adjudicative or determinative ADR processes when adjudication is available in the court?
Brian Hutchinson:
Well there are some simple answers to that and there's some deeper philosophical answers to it, but I'll start with the simple one. You know, when you go to court, you're limited to the court docket, or as we might call list here in this part of the world. So there might be reasons why you would want to take your adjudication into what's sometimes argued as a more efficient or at least a more controllable timeframe. Expertise, the person you get to adjudicate might be somebody who's expert in the sphere of dispute or knowledgeable in the factual elements of the dispute.
And therefore we get an efficiency or gain in efficiency there. We might look for privacy, you know, we don't want to necessarily air our dirty linen in public. And sometimes commercially that can be the kiss of death to a project or a business. You don't want your competitors knowing that you're in dispute with your suppliers or your employees, for example. So we might look for privacy. And sometimes it is true that by taking things away from the formal courts, we also perhaps allow a different or a better space for maintaining the relationship between us.
I think it's a fallacy to assume that arbitration is softer than litigation, for example. Or that adjudication is softer than arbitration. Each of them can be as vicious or more than the other, but well managed. And with good intent, it is possible to create a softer or a better environment for dispute resolution as well. So they're kind of the simple approaches to it. I might say that, I mean, if we took through the world of dispute resolution from a slightly more philosophical perspective and asked ourselves what we want in society and how we want society to manage itself, I mean there is a premium to be placed on creating space for parties to resolve their disputes privately.
There is a need for adjudicative dispute resolution because sometimes neither of us can decide why the crack in the road was there, and we need somebody to point out that it was because the foundation was wrong rather than it was badly designed. And so there is a need for that, but also perhaps if you take it even further, litigation and the courts are provided by the state. And if you think about historically why that is, it's partly to keep the citizens peaceful and happy and, and not revolting.
And it's partly to exert the will of the sovereign. Now in the 21st century, you know, we're privileged to be in parts of the world where those aren't huge issues, but if you want to a society which perhaps allows for real justice, whatever that is, then you need a space for private dispute resolution, whether it's adjudicative or facilitative, of course, as well. So from a deeper perspective, there is a need still for private adjudicative processes as well. They're not just efficiencies to get us to where we would be with litigation without having to pay as much.
Alternative dispute resolution, on the other hand, has many benefits. Both arbitration and mediation tend to be more cost-effective, and usually take less time than a court case.
There is a greater chance that parties will arrive at a mutually beneficial solution, and personal and business relationships are more likely to be preserved.
Mediators and arbitrators also have specialised training in resolving disputes.
Arbitration and mediation are both alternative dispute resolution processes that take place outside of court.
In arbitration, a third party arbitrator makes a decision, whereas in mediation the parties decide what the outcome will be. They do this with the assistance of a neutral mediator who facilitates negotiations,
Arbitration tends to be a more formal process and looks a little more like a court process than mediation does. The arbitrator, who usually has legal knowledge, makes a final and binding decision, which is called an award.
In mediation, which is a voluntary process, the two parties involved work with a mediator to solve problems and find a settlement.
Both dispute resolution processes play an important role in modern legal practice, as more parties want a quicker and more cost-efficient way of resolving disputes than court processes. A judge may also require parties to engage in mediation in the UK, and this is something that is happening more frequently.
To learn more about a career in arbitration sign up for our introductory course in arbitration led by one of the UK's leading arbitration scholars.

Comparative Analysis: Mediation vs. Arbitration in the UK
Mediation is typically informal, flexible, and guided by the needs and preferences of the parties involved. The process usually begins with an introductory session where the mediator explains the rules and goals of mediation.
Parties then have opportunities to present their perspectives to the mediator and to each other and work towards finding common ground.
The structure of mediation is a flexible and can be tailored to different types of disputes. The mediator's role is to facilitate the discussions and assist the parties in negotiation. To learn in more detail what is mediation check out one of our other posts where we compare it to other forms of ADR.
Arbitration is a more structured and formal procedure to resolve a dispute. It often resembles a court hearing, though it is generally less rigid and happens more quickly. The arbitration process usually begins with a preliminary hearing in which the arbitrator sets the ground rules, followed by the presentation of evidence and witness testimonies.
The arbitrator may ask questions, request additional evidence, and set deadlines. Arbitration hearings are usually held in private, and the process follows specific procedural rules that vary depending on the arbitration agreement or governing institution.
Dr Julio-César Betancourt walks through a typical arbitration, from the request for arbitration to the award, and explains why appeals are rare.
Interviewer: Could you talk me through how an arbitration process typically works? Cause it sounds a lot like a court process.
Dr Julio-César Betancourt:
Yes. Most arbitral proceedings will begin with a request for arbitration and a response to the request. And that is followed by a series of pleadings. So in a sense there are certain aspects of the arbitration process that are quite similar to what we do when we go to court. So you would have a statement of claim a state of defence and counterclaim, if any and that is followed by a reply and a rejoinder. Once the parties have exchanged pleadings there would be usually a hearing.
We could be talking about a one day hearing, a five day hearing, two week hearing. Everything will depend on the complexity of the case. The tribunal, if its one single arbitrator the arbitrator will proceed to prepare an award. You were talking about a three-person arbitration tribunal. They would normally have some deliberations. And after that, they will go off to write an award. So the arbiter's tribunal role right after arbitral proceedings have been carried out is to put an end to the parties dispute by means of an award.
International commercial arbitration appeals are actually very rare. Under English law, the parties could potentially make an appeal on the section 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996. However, that is not a mandatory provision. And therefore the parties do not necessarily have to incorporate an appeal within the arbitration process. Under Section 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996, the court will be essentially entrusted with the task of hearing the appeal outside the framework of English arbitration law. The parties could potentially set up a different tribunal who will essentially hear the appeal, but that again is very rarely seen in practise.
As a rule, arbitration tends to cost more than mediation, as the process takes longer and often requires special expertise. The arbitrator is often a lawyer or a retired judge, and usually has some expertise related to the specific circumstances of the case. The outcome is almost always a final decision that is legally binding.
Is arbitration cheaper than going to court? Not always, says Brian Hutchinson. It carries legal overheads that litigation does not, but its binding award, enforceable internationally, can save parties from fighting the same dispute in several countries at once.
Interviewer: What about the cost of arbitration compared to litigation or mediation or conciliation?
Brian Hutchinson:
Ah. Well, sometimes, people will choose arbitration believing that it will be cheaper than mediation, cheaper than litigation, particularly, or some other processes. And they may be right. But when you put the two processes alongside each other, let's say litigation and arbitration, well, you have additional overheads with arbitration. And these overheads are not just the nones for the use of the hall or the hiring of the venue but are the paying of the arbitrator. As I've said before, the overheads are the need for additional law to support the process.
Is there an arbitration agreement? Is it valid? What's within its scope? Does the arbitrator have jurisdiction to deal with these kind of issues? Does the arbitrator have jurisdiction to decide whether the arbitrator is an arbitrator? These are things you just don't have to deal with in litigation. And so, arbitration can be much more expensive and much more time-consuming and much more complex than litigation. On the other hand, in long-term savings, and also in terms of, you know, fireproofing, I'll explain that in a moment, it can be much more efficient and cost-effective.
What I mean in terms of long-term savings would be that it is possible to be much more efficient in the delivery of arbitration, because you're not competing with other events or other cases in the court list. Your arbitrator is available, your parties are available, and we can perhaps conduct the thing more quickly or efficiently or more flexibly, even, that way. So there could be savings there. But what I meant in terms of fireproofing is that, because of the New York Convention, and because of the binding nature of arbitration, if you agree to arbitrate in Dublin, then that's your dispute solution.
And if somebody starts litigation in New York and Paris and Russia and Singapore, by having arbitration, you do not have to put out five different fires all on the same topic in five different places. It's fireproofing against concurrent, contiguous litigation. And that could end up saving parties fortunes. Absolutely. I have been in arbitrations, and I think many of the arbitrations I've been in are advised, and where the costs of the process have quickly gone beyond the amounts in dispute. And the arbitration became an arbitration over who was responsible for costs.
So I like to remind parties that when considering whether it is an appropriate dispute resolution mechanism, they need to look beyond the cost factor, or at least think of costs differently.
Mediation costs less as the process is often confined to one day, with some preparatory and follow up meetings. The mediator might be a lawyer or a retired judge, or might be from a different professional background. The outcome is an agreement that the parties agree on, that might take the form of a signed settlement agreement, or sometimes a court order.
Each method has advantages and disadvantages. Arbitration can be quite technical, and it can take a long time to receive the award. However, the fact that the award is a binding decision is very important to many parties to a dispute, and it is still more efficient than going to court.
Dr Julio-César Betancourt on why arbitration has become complex, lengthy and costly: "It is precisely that flexibility that makes arbitration a victim of its own success."
Interviewer: What are the disadvantages of arbitration?
Dr Julio-César Betancourt:
Arbitration has become complex, lengthy and costly. And that is primarily because arbitration is a truly flexible mechanism. The parties retain full control over the process. It is precisely that flexibility that makes arbitration a victim of its own success. And the main disadvantage of arbitration is perhaps, that the parties do not have control over the outcome. And that is, of course, what's commonly found in any third-party decision making process.
Mediation is less formal, and the parties voluntarily work together to resolve the dispute by negotiation. This can improve relationships between the parties. It is particularly suitable for situations where the parties might have to have ongoing discussions, such as in the case of divorce, for example. It can result in a binding agreement, but additional steps may have to be taken. These are just some of the benefits of mediation and why many disputants are turning to mediation as a serious alternative to court.
One of the fundamental differences between mediation and arbitration is who makes the decision. In mediation, the parties retain full control over the outcome. They do not have to reach an agreement, and if one party can't agree to resolve the matter the mediator ends. If this happens, the parties may choose to resolve the dispute via avenues such as arbitration or litigation.
In arbitration, the arbitrator has the sole authority to decide the outcome. The arbitrator’s decision, known as an award, is usually binding and enforceable, similar to a court judgment. This means that once an arbitrator has rendered a decision, the parties must comply with it, and there are limited grounds for appeal.
A range of different disputes can be resolved by arbitration and mediation. Interpersonal conflicts, such as those arising out of divorce or workplace conflict are very suitable for mediation. In these cases, the parties are often best placed to decide the terms of a settlement, and this type of facilitated negotiation has many benefits for the future relationship of those involved. Business disputes are also well suited to commercial mediation especially where there's a need to maintain ongoing commercial relationships.
While it can be difficult for parties to engage in negotiation directly, having a mediator to help them reach a solution often makes things easier.
Arbitration, while more costly, can be beneficial where a claim has a lot of technical and commercial aspects. Arbitrators can, for example, get other experts involved to give evidence and inform their decision. The fact that it is a private dispute resolution process is also useful, as it is often attractive for commercial entities such as companies to keep the terms of the settlement private.
To learn directly from some of the experts in the field watch this clip with full time Arbitrator Tim Hardy.
In this next video, Professor Bryan Clark, one the UK's leading dispute resolution scholar's describe the benefits of mediation for resolving disputes.
Recent Changes in ADR Legislation in the UK
Much of the law around mediation arbitration and other processes are contained in caselaw in the UK. Some new developments include rulings that parties can be compelled to attempt mediation before going to court, even though it is a voluntary process.
This happens quite frequently at present, as the government and the judiciary are keen to promote different forms of dispute resolution.
Pre-arbitration mediation is a dispute resolution strategy that involves attempting mediation before proceeding to arbitration when a conflict arises. This approach is often stipulated in contracts through a "mediation-arbitration" (med-arb) clause, which requires the parties to try mediation first as a means of resolving their dispute.
If this fails to produce an agreement, the parties then engage an arbitrator as the next step. This two-tiered approach offers the advantages of both processes, making it a popular option for resolving conflicts efficiently.
Can the same person act as mediator and then arbitrator? Julio-César Betancourt explains the risks of med-arb, and the alternative, arb-med, in which the award is written first and sealed in an envelope while the parties try mediation.
Interviewer: How can a mediator arbitrator simultaneously manage both those roles.
Dr Julio-César Betancourt:
It is very difficult for the same person to perform both roles. And that is actually one of the main criticisms that made up has received mainly because of the risk of unconscious bias. Now, there is also further risk and that is that the parties may not be willing to give away or to exchange the information that they would normally exchange when there is no threat of arbitration. Under Spanish arbitration law, for instance, mediators are not allowed to act as arbitrators within the same dispute unless the parties agree.
But there is a way around. So, rather than having med-arb, you could have arb-med. And the way it works is that the arbitrator will arbitrate the parties dispute in the traditional fashion. The award is usually placed in an envelope and that envelope is put away. Then the arbitrator will try to mediate that dispute. And if the parties are not able to reach an agreement then the award will be released. So there is an incentive in the sense of the parties may prevent the release of the award if they manage to reach an agreement in mediation Yes.
I think as a mediator, he or she will be able to assess the parties, strengths and weaknesses in a way that they will try to kind of help the parties to have more, a more realistic more realistic expectations. Now that you know exactly what the dispute is all about and in the international commercial arena we're talking about whether or not you have breached the contract, so we're talking about legal issues, I think that the arbitrator will be able to have the parties to better understand how strong or how weak the case is.
And I think that is possible, it's possible. So long as you remain impartial. So I'm not, I'm not that worried about that but the other way around is a lot harder. It's a lot harder.
%2520(1).jpeg)
Both mediation and arbitration are attractive alternatives to going to court.
If parties want to save money and time, these are good dispute resolution options. An additional benefit is that while the parties can't select judges for their case, they can select from a list or register of arbitrators or mediators based on their subject matter expertise, experience and availability.
If you want to improve your knowledge of Mediation you can sign up to one of our mediation courses and open up new career opportunities.
Whether arbitration mediation or another process is best depends on the type of conflict and the needs of the parties. Where ongoing relationships are involved, confidentiality is important and the parties can negotiate together in a collaborative way, mediation is a great option.
For more complex and technical disputes, finding an arbitrator that has the necessary expertise and technical knowledge can mean a swift and private settlement.
Both processes have distinct benefits over traditional litigation, each with distinct advantages and limitations. Mediation is a collaborative, flexible, and non-binding process that empowers parties to craft their resolutions. It is ideal for preserving relationships and fostering mutual agreements in a confidential and informal setting.
Arbitration, on the other hand, provides a more formal, binding, and enforceable resolution similar to a private court proceeding, making it suitable for complex or high-stakes disputes.
Understanding the differences between these two ADR methods helps individuals and businesses make informed decisions about how best to resolve their disputes, ensuring the chosen process aligns with their goals, needs, and the nature of their conflict.
If you're curious about ADR and in particular what a career might look like either in arbitration or mediation then sign up to on of our introductory Mediation Courses today.